Coaching the Kid Who Wants to Win Every Time
How to point a competitive streak at something that lasts longer than the scoreboard
Every coach knows this kid. They sprint to the front of the line, keep score when nobody else is counting, and argue every close call. When their team loses a relay, the tears or the protests come fast. Sometimes they cut a corner to get there first: running when the game called for a bear crawl, or skipping the last cone.
It is tempting to see that drive as a problem to manage. It is not. A competitive streak is energy, and energy is the raw material of growth. The coach’s job is not to put the fire out. It is to point it at something that lasts longer than one race.
Why “win at all costs” backfires
One of the best-known studies in motivation research helps explain what’s happening inside a kid who has to win. In 1998, Claudia Mueller and Carol Dweck gave fifth graders a set of puzzles and then praised them in one of two ways. Some heard they must be smart. Others heard they must have worked hard. Then every child faced a set of problems that was too difficult for their age.
The differences were striking. Children praised for being smart were more likely to choose easy problems afterward, enjoyed the task less after failing, and performed worse on the next set. They were also more likely to misrepresent their scores. Children praised for effort chose harder problems they could learn from and bounced back better.
When kids believe a result shows who they are, losing stops being an event and starts feeling like a verdict. The child who must win every time is often protecting something: the idea that they are “the fast one” or “the good one.” Shortcuts and meltdowns make more sense through that lens.
Pressure drains the fun, even for the winners
There is a second reason to rethink how much the scoreboard matters. The Aspen Institute’s Project Play, working with the Utah State University Families in Sports Lab, surveyed more than 1,000 parents of young athletes in 2019. On average, children quit a sport after less than three years, around age 11. The most common reason was that the sport just wasn’t fun anymore, cited in 36% of cases. Parents also named coaches as the biggest source of pressure on their kids.
Picture a typical relay. Four teams line up, one team wins, and three teams lose. Run it five times and most kids in the gym have lost more often than they’ve won. If winning is the only thing that gets celebrated, that adds up to a lot of time feeling like you came up short. Now picture the same relay where every team is chasing its own best time and its cleanest form. Suddenly every team has something to cheer about, and the kid who always wants to win has a new target: beating yesterday.
When the whole session revolves around who wins, most kids spend most of their time losing. Even the child who usually wins carries the weight of needing to keep winning. That’s a recipe for burnout, not growth.
Change what counts as winning
The Positive Coaching Alliance offers a simple frame coaches can use right away: the ELM Tree of Mastery. ELM stands for Effort, Learning and Mistakes are OK. Effort is worth measuring because it’s within a child’s control. Learning is a goal in every practice. And mistakes are expected, because a kid who fears mistakes won’t try anything new.
As one Positive Coaching Alliance resource puts it, “Winning on the scoreboard can be a by product of players learning and improving.” And: “Being a mastery winner is more important, more satisfying and should be the end goal.”
Competitive kids do not need less to compete for. They need better things to compete for: beating their own best, keeping perfect form when they’re tired, or being the loudest encourager on the team.
Seven moves for your next session
Redefine the race before it starts. “Today, everyone is racing their own best time,” or “The winning team is the one that keeps its form the whole way.”
Praise the process, specifically. Swap “You’re so fast!” for “You kept your bear crawl even when your arms got tired.”
Give them a job. Competitive kids often make great demonstrators and helpers. Ask them to show the move or coach a younger child through it.
Make integrity part of the game. If someone takes a shortcut, the rule is a restart, not a punishment. “Strong means doing it all the way.”
Build a mistake ritual. A quick shared gesture, like brushing off a shoulder, helps kids let go of an error and move to the next try.
Debrief losses with questions. “What did you learn? What will you try next time?” moves the focus from the result to the next step.
Talk one-on-one. A private moment of “I noticed how much you care about doing well. Let’s use that to get even better” lands differently than a correction in front of the group.
When the meltdown comes anyway
Even with the best setup, a loss will sometimes hit hard. Stay calm and stay close. Name what you see (“That really mattered to you”) and give the child a moment before asking anything. Once they’re settled, ask one question: “What’s one thing you did well in that race?” Then invite them back in. The goal isn’t to make the disappointment disappear. It’s to show that disappointment is survivable, and that the next try is always available.
The fire is worth keeping
The kid who wants to win every time often becomes the hardest worker on the team, once winning means growing. When a coach helps that child aim their drive at effort, learning and recovery, the competitive streak stops being something to manage. It becomes something to celebrate.
Sources
Mueller, C. M., & Dweck, C. S. (1998). Praise for intelligence can undermine children’s motivation and performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1), 33–52. Summary
Solomon, J. (2019). Survey: Kids quit most sports by age 11. Project Play, The Aspen Institute. projectplay.org
Positive Coaching Alliance. Coaching: The ELM Tree of Mastery. Jr. NBA. jr.nba.com
Comments